In the search for energy independence, the “dream team” has always been Solar PV combined with a wind turbine. The logic is seductive: Solar covers the long summer days, and wind picks up the slack during the dark, stormy winter months. It is the perfect theoretical marriage of seasonal energy.
However, after extensive research and market analysis for our project, we have decided to stick exclusively with solar.
While we remain open to testing wind technology in the future, we cannot currently recommend a domestic wind turbine that meets our standards for reliability and cost-effectiveness. Here is why we made that decision.
The Economics: Solar is Winning the Race
The primary driver of our decision is the sheer disparity in Cost Per Watt.
-
Solar PV: The mature market has driven prices down to approximately €1.20 – €2.00 per Watt installed. It is a commodity technology that offers a predictable, guaranteed return on investment (often 5–7 years).
-
Domestic Wind: To get a reputable, reliable machine, the cost jumps to €4.00 – €8.00+ per Watt.
For the price of a single 3kW wind turbine setup, we can install a significantly larger solar array and expand our battery storage. That extra battery capacity provides a more reliable buffer against winter darkness than an unpredictable wind turbine.
The Physics of “Small” Wind
We found that domestic wind suffers from a scaling problem known as the Square-Cube Law. Wind turbines do not scale down well.
-
Micro-turbines (under 1.5m diameter): These units often struggle to overcome their own internal friction. While they may spin rapidly, they rarely generate meaningful amperage to charge a home battery bank.
-
The “Swept Area” Rule: To power a home (running washing machines, heat pumps, etc.), a turbine needs a rotor diameter of at least 2.5 to 3 metres. This moves the unit out of “DIY/Garden” territory and into “Civil Engineering” territory, requiring concrete foundations, heavy steel towers, and strict planning permissions.
Reliability vs. Maintenance
Solar panels have no moving parts. They are a “fit and forget” technology that can last 25+ years with almost zero maintenance.
Wind turbines are dynamic machines fighting against the elements. They require:
-
Annual Maintenance: Greasing bearings, checking brake systems, and inspecting blades.
-
Repair Costs: In high winds, moving parts break. Inverters for wind turbines are also more prone to failure than solar inverters due to the erratic nature of the voltage input.
For our project, we prioritised reliability. We did not want a system that required constant tinkering or specialised technicians to keep running.
The “Wild West” Marketplace
Our research uncovered a polarised market in Europe with very little middle ground:
-
The High End (e.g., SD Wind Energy, Bornay): These manufacturers build incredible, reliable machines. However, they are priced for industrial or high-end off-grid estates, making them financially unviable for a standard domestic project.
-
The “Online Kit” Trap: Marketplaces are flooded with cheap imported turbines (often advertised as “3kW” or “5kW”) that are physically incapable of delivering that power. Many of these units have poor reliability records and overstated performance claims.
We could not find a “mid-range” option that offered the reliability of the high-end brands at a price point that made sense for a residential project.
Our Verdict
For now, the maths favours Solar.
We are maximising our solar array and investing in battery storage to bridge the winter gap. While we are disappointed not to harness the wind—especially for that valuable winter energy—the technology for small-scale residential wind is simply not as mature or cost-effective as photovoltaics.
However, we are not closing the door on wind forever. We are keeping a close eye on developments in vertical-axis (VAWT) wind turbines and new motionless wind-harvesting technologies. If we find a unit that passes our reliability and cost tests, we will be the first to pilot it.
But for today, if you ask us for a recommendation, our answer is simple: Buy more solar panels.